Our Company

Providing Quality Insurance 
For Over 50 Years



American Trust Insurance Services is your independent agency that works for you, not the insurance company. Our goal is to protect our client's best interest in providing the right insurance policies at the right price. Our staff is dedicated to providing our clients with a high level of customer service. We build relationships with our clients based on trust and understanding of their specific situation.
Insurance Claim — Engraved W on Concrete Near Shoreline in Whiting, IN

Meet Our Team

Susan Polak
Commercial Lines Producer / Manager
📠 219-473-5527
Tina Arroyo
Personal Lines Producer
📠 219-473-5527
Sue Ann Dvorscak
Life & Health Producer
📠 219-473-5527
Lisa Hrabovsky
Personal Lines Producer/Claims 
📠 219-473-5527
Ann Gottschammer
Personal Lines Producer
📠 219-473-5527
Share by: